End of The Commons General Store

Serving the needs of the people since 1840

Best Fry Pies in Amish Country

Authentically Amish Hand-Made Fry Pies

You know you’re in Amish Country when you’ve had a fry pie. So popular with Amish folks in our area, fry pies are like mini pies you can eat with your hand, no fork needed. Delicious pie filling and homemade dough, they are fried then sealed with a sweet vanilla-flavored glaze. Made right here in our bakery by Amish bakers.

Note: All products are produced in a facility and on equipment that also processes Milk, Eggs, Wheat, Peanuts, Tree Nuts, Soybeans, Fish, and Shellfish.

Get One Extra Fry Pie For Every 12 Fry Pies Ordered!

“The Best Apple Fry Pie I’ve Ever Had…”

Store Highlights

Built in 1840 End of the Commons General Store is Ohio's oldest operating general store. We are located in the heart of Amish country in historic Mesopotamia, Ohio and only 40 minutes east of Cleveland. We stock over 1,000 bulk food products, hard to find housewares & kitchen gadgets, home made fudge, hand dipped ice cream, over 150 varieties of old fashioned soda & penny candy. Stop in for lunch or dinner at the Commons Cafe. Sample many foods from Amish country & enjoy a trip into the past!

The Schaden Family Business

The End of The Commons General Store is a true "General Store" that has been serving the needs of the people since 1840.  Our shelves are lined with great old fashioned quality products that your grandparents were used to.  We work very hard to bring you familiar items of yesteryear.  Our products will not only simplify your life but are classic memories of times gone by.  If you would like to visit one of THE largest Amish community in the United States, then come to Mesopotamia, Ohio, and stop by to visit with us.  We would love to have you browse around our store! Come relax on our front porch rocker with a hand-dipped ice cream cone and experience a tranquil way of life! There's plenty to see and do in Mesopotamia!

Ready to Visit? See Our Contact Page for Directions!

We are easy to get to. We are in the heart of Amish Country, in Northeast Ohio. There is plenty to do and see when you get here. You can easily walk around a town filled with other shops and merchants.